Independent Study Reveals Gaps in Traveler Protection from
Credit Cards, Health Care Plans and Homeowner's Insurance

Travel Insurance Market Analysis Exposes Myths
and Misconceptions of Travel Insurance

Boston, MA - An independent study by research and consulting firm Chadwick Martin Bailey, Inc. shows that travel-related insurance offerings by credit cards, health care plans and homeowner's insurance often fall short of coverage offered by providers of comprehensive travel insurance. The study, commissioned by Travel Guard International, the nation's leading provider of travel insurance, revealed that U.S. travelers may be traveling under the assumption that they have more insurance against travel-related problems than is actually the case.

"There is considerable confusion among the traveling public over just what travel insurance covers," notes Judy Melanson, project manager and Vice President at Chadwick Martin Bailey. "In order to uncover some of the myths and misconceptions about travel insurance, we compared a typical travel insurance policy with the travel-related coverage available from a cross-section of credit cards, health insurance plans and homeowner's policies. While those products sometimes provide limited coverage for travel-related problems, there are often exclusions and conditions that even the most thorough traveler can miss. With a comprehensive travel insurance policy from a third-party provider, a traveler knows that he or she is not vulnerable to gaps in coverage."

Key findings of the market analysis include:

  • Trip Cancellation/Trip Interruption - A comprehensive travel insurance policy is the only source of trip cancellation coverage available to travelers for reasons of illness, injury, inclement weather, jury duty or organized labor strikes. A complete travel insurance policy will reimburse a traveler for the pre-paid, unused, non-refundable portion of a trip payment, plus the cost of returning home or rejoining the trip. Credit cards do not offer trip cancellation coverage.
  • Medical Expenses - Most comprehensive travel insurance policies cover necessary medical and surgical expenses while traveling, usually as primary coverage. Primary coverage means that the
    travel insurance company will pay the traveler first, rather than supplementing any payment by the traveler's health plan or HMO. Domestic medical plans generally provide some coverage outside of the United States, but a traveler must carefully review the fine print to understand conditions and exclusions, since some plans only cover emergency care. Travelers with Medicare are not covered outside of the U.S.
  • Medical Evacuation - Emergency medical evacuation and transportation to the nearest adequate medical facilities is a standard benefit of most comprehensive travel insurance plans. While some credit cards will arrange emergency medical transportation, it is always at the cardholder's expense. The more compete travel insurance plans will also pay airfare for a special medical escort if recommended by the attending doctor.
  • Baggage Protection - A comprehensive travel insurance policy that covers lost or damaged baggage will often provide coverage above and beyond the standard reimbursement by the airlines. A travel insurance policy that offers comprehensive baggage protection will not only pay for damage to or loss of baggage, but may also take over baggage tracking by liaising with airlines to find and return lost luggage to insured travelers. Homeowner's insurance, conversely, may not cover bags that are stolen, and may only cover bags that are damaged by "fire and water."
  • Car Rental Accident Insurance - A dedicated car rental collision damage policy that pays "primary coverage" will pay for damage to a rental car, regardless of the insured renter's personal auto insurance coverage, and will protect a traveler against the threat of higher future premiums. Personal auto insurance, when used to insure a rental car, is subject to premium increases and insurance surcharges in the event of an accident. Some credit cards also offer car rental protection when the card is used to pay for the rental, but most coverage is secondary, and will only cover expenses that are not covered by personal auto insurance.

About Chadwick Martin Bailey
Chadwick Martin Bailey (chadwickmartinbailey.com) is a Boston-based research and consulting firm that uses primary and secondary research and measurement to help its clients identify and penetrate markets, develop products, improve service delivery and build brand value. Tour and travel clients include Hilton Hotels, Saga Holidays, Harrah's Entertainment and AAA.